The UK government, according to First Minister Humza Yousaf, has put the deposit return scheme (DRS) in "grave danger.".
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has received a letter from Mr. Yousaf imploring him to reverse the UK government's decision to reject glass in the program by Monday.
He predicted that the requirements would "significantly impact" business.
Deposit return programs needed to be uniform across the UK, according to the Scotland Office of the UK government.
The DRS, which is scheduled to go into effect in Scotland in March of next year, will not apply to glass containers, according to a letter it sent to the Scottish government last week.
Now, Mr. Yousaf has written to the prime minister pleading for a change of heart and citing objections from one of Scotland's largest brewers.
In his letter, he stated that the elimination of glass "fundamentally threatens the viability of Scotland's DRS with reduced revenue for the scheme administrator.".
The removal of glass will significantly affect business.
For instance, the UK government's decision to ban glass explicitly threatens investment and jobs, according to Candamp;C Group, the owners of the venerable Tennent's brand.
"Similar issues have been privately brought up with us by other Scottish businesses. ".
The decision led to yet another constitutional dispute between Edinburgh and London, with the first minister writing: "The decision has much wider ramifications.
"This late-stage intervention by the UK government shows how seriously the devolution agreement has deteriorated.
"I implore you to revoke the terms of your letter and grant a full exclusion for Scotland's DRS, to be carried out in accordance with the rules approved by the Scottish Parliament in this area of devolved competence.
Without this, the Scottish government is unwilling to subject Scottish companies to a competitive disadvantage as a result of the UK government's hurried demands.
There's no denying that your government's actions have seriously jeopardized DRS's future, not just in Scotland but also in the rest of the UK because they've undermined investor and consumer confidence. ".
The Scottish system's "interoperability" with the upcoming English DRS, which is scheduled to go live in October 2025, was one of the additional requirements placed on the plan.
The first minister acknowledged that having the ability for the schemes to cooperate where possible would be "desirable," but added that because it was still so early, the UK government was "unable to provide the operational details required to allow the schemes to be interoperable.".
Businesses need certainty now, he continued, not two years from now, when the UK government scheme may or may not begin.
"The clarity and certainty that businesses universally agree they need have been seriously undermined by the UK government. ".
Mr. Yousaf also emphasized that from 2019 through March 2022, or two years after the Scottish Parliament passed regulations, the UK government intended to include glass in the English DRS.
We used this information to plan our scheme, he said.
The UK government confirmed in January 2023, according to the first minister, that it was up to devolved governments to determine the parameters of their DRSdot.
According to Mr. Yousaf, "The English scheme is out of step with the design of other UK schemes" because the Welsh government has stated that they intend to include glass in their DRS.
The Scottish Cabinet will discuss the matter the following day, and the first minister requested a response from Downing Street by Monday to inform Holyrood.
A spokeswoman for the Scotland Office stated that the government would respond to the first minister's letter as soon as possible and continued, "The government remains unwavering in its commitment to improving the environment while also upholding the UK's internal market.
The Scottish government reviewed and suspended their program earlier this year after receiving complaints from the drinks industry about how their DRS differed from plans in the rest of the UK.
We have taken note of these worries, which is why we granted the Scottish government's request for a temporary and limited UKIM exclusion in order to make sure that its plan is consistent with those for the rest of the UK. ".
The spokeswoman continued, "Deposit return schemes need to be uniform throughout the UK, and this is the best way to offer a straightforward and efficient system.
"A UK-wide system with uniform rules will boost recycling collection rates, cut litter, cause the least amount of disruption to the beverage industry, and ensure consumer convenience.
. "
